Okay, okay – so the bad news is that Star’s Hollow doesn’t exist in real life- but the good news is there are dozens and dozens of gorgeous New England towns even more beautiful than our favorite Connecticut movie set. From Maine to Rhode Island, we’ve gathered our list of the quaintest, coziest New England spots to visit this fall.

Bar Harbor, Maine

$32 per person a night / Sleeps 16

Rent here

Old Lyme, Connecticut

$66 per person a night / Sleeps 4

Rent here

Newport, Rhode Island

$56 per person a night / Sleeps 4

Rent here

Quechee, Vermont

$25 per person a night / Sleeps 8

Rent here

Ogunquit, Maine

$80 per person a night / Sleeps 25

Rent here

Stowe, Vermont

$125 per person a night / Sleeps 16

Rent here

Machiasport, Maine

$43 per person a night / Sleeps 4

Rent here

Salem, Massachusetts

$39 per person a night / Sleeps 4

Rent here

Portsmouth, New Hampshire

$125 per person a month / Sleeps 6

Rent here

Woodstock, Vermont

$28 per person a night / Sleeps 8

Rent here

Nantucket, Massachusetts

142 per person a night / Sleeps 7

Rent here